After swearing off the Vast Vacuity that is Facebook for some weeks, I am back on. I still think there’s a way to make it worthwhile, perhaps by kicking off all the friends who are giving me grief – kind of like life.
Anyway, I am learning from Facebook the appalling state of Reason in the post-modern world. I link there to my posts here at the Ink Desk, and I often receive comments there on my posts here. My point in my most recent post (“The Sterility of Culture” – see below) was, “We use various ways to opt out of life and retreat into self-indulgent shells and this is part of the Culture of Sterility”. One of the Facebook commenters said, “Stop bashing technology! Ipods and computer networking are not bad things!” Thus he confused my critique of ends (cutting oneself off from interaction) with a critique of means (the technology used to do so).
Elsewhere on Facebook I was very critical of the five bishops from the USCCB who issued a statement on Catholic – Jewish relations in which they said dialogue with the Jews, “’has never been and never will be used by the Catholic Church as a means of proselytism,” nor is it a “disguised invitation to baptism”, a statement I called “despicable”. To deny the Great Commission is perhaps worse than Peter’s three-fold denial of Our Lord.
This elicited at least one strong objection from a Facebook commenter who compared interfaith dialogue with the Jews to setting up a law firm in which one partner is Christian and one is Jewish and they both agree to “leave religion out of the office”. He went on to say that we should not be heavy handed when it comes to evangelization and that listening is as important as talking, etc.
Again we have confusion of means with ends. Our end in all of our dealings with all people should be to call them to baptism, and to proselytize by showing forth our love for Jesus. There is never any dialogue or human interaction in which this end – the call to salvation, either by our silent witness or our spoken witness – should be ignored or renounced. Thus what I call despicable is not the bishops’ assurance to the Jews that we will listen to them and not try to strong-arm them into baptism (means they did not renounce) but the assurance to the Jews that we will not proselytize them nor call them to baptism (ends they did renounce).
But there’s a creeping devil at the root of this. The confusion of my Facebook friends leads to something dark and sickly and ultimately insane.
If I were to sit down for an interfaith dialogue with a Jew, a Muslim, and an atheist, for example, I would certainly hope that each of them would try to proselytize me, try to convert me to their own faiths or points of view. If any of them were so lackluster about his faith or his philosophy that he wouldn’t bother to try to convert me to it, I would wonder what kind of thing this faith or philosophy of his was and why, if he thought it was right or true, he would not try to make a case for it and defend it.
This post-modern tentativity, this squeamishness and unwillingness to commit, this desire to “leave religion out of the office”, even when the “office” is a room where an interfaith dialogue is supposed to occur, is all based on the dreadful lie that religion is a private subjective thing, a mere matter of taste, a benevolent delusion that has no bearing on the truth or on reality. What gives the lie to this lie is that it is not content to hold itself to religion – it spreads to everything. The devil overplays his hand. He not only denies that God is truth but denies that anything can be true.
And so we can not discuss anything, for it is no longer allowed that we can take a stand on anything or convince another that we believe in anything. Without truth there can be no Reason, and without Reason you end up with the post-modern malaise, including the bizarre field of communication called Facebook where discussion has taken a back seat to flashy pictures and “status updates”.
Whether my Facebook friends who read this post can manage to see past the emotional diversions of the Jewish issue, the discomfort when a layman criticizes anti-Christian bishops, or the bare mention of the word “atheist” remains to be seen. Comments, anyone?
Chesterton held that we’re breeding men too intellectually humble to believe in the multiplication table. He deplored the “misplaced” virtue of humility in modern reasoning which results in the heresy-caveat applied to every pronouncement of beliefs: “Of course, I may be wrong.” And he deplored it because, as you observe, it is deplorable.
There’s a saying which one thinks would be indicative of the modern milk-toast ecumenism about “agreeing to disagree.” But in plain fact, the modern “dialogue” falls short even of this. At least if we could agree that there IS a disagreement, that might be a starting point. If people agreed not to have a discussion because they wanted to keep peace for the time being, or that the time wasn’t ripe, or that it would only lead to rancor – that MIGHT be respectable. But that would be agreement upon the fact that there IS a matter to be disagreed about. That would at least acknowledge that there was something deep and meaningful at the heart of things which was the reason for our pad-footing it around the issue.
But the most recent models of ecumenism and inter-faith dialogue don’t even get so far as acknowledging that. They’re all crowded to the walls by the massive elephant in the room and talk about anything but the pachyderm. It’s “you’re okay, I’m okay” and not even an acknowledgement that one or the other party must be wrong at least about something and that there is at least substance to the disagreement. Thank God that Pope Benedict at least shows the gumption to acknowledge (with the Anglicans) not only that the elephant exists, but that something can be done about it.
In social media facebook provide excellent service.Especially we can add custom pages is important one in facebook.[url=http://squarepegweb.us/2010/06/square-peg-web-make-your-website-as-unique-as-you-are/]square peg web[/url]
Excellent! i have read about this for the first time and found very interesting.
I agree, I think too many people have used social media as a wall between themselves and good, honest, REAL relationships with people. This may be a pet peeve, but I seriously don’t understand why someone would bother typing a short text message on their cell phone to a “friend” as opposed to making a quick, short phone call. It’s a cell phone! Call someone! Printing Las Vegas
A strong foundation serves as a stand or platform in which the organization can centralize its information and direct customers on its recent developments via other social media channels, such as article and press release publications. [url=http://www.localmarketingsource.com/blog/defining-small-business-service-areas-for-local-seo]local seo[/url]
I like this blog. Thanks for having it. I will be back for updates.
f I were to sit down for an interfaith dialogue with a Jew, a Muslim, and an atheist, for example, I would certainly hope that each of them would try to proselytize me, try to convert me to their own faiths or points of view
facebook layouts.
Great chance with whatever trend of accomplished you decide to follow.
[url=”http://www.stubbyholdersdirect.com.au/”]wedding stubby holders[/url]
Very advisory article. Keep autograph such admirable articles.
Wedding Bomboniere
I think it is an amazing situation, but feel that almost people already experience about it.
[url=”http://www.jaysxlist.com/”]montreal massage parlor[/url]
I expected a little more on the topic.. hoping for more in the future
Bankruptcy Attorney
http://www.bankruptcyattorneyincalifornia.com
According to comScore, an internet marketing research company, Facebook collects as much data from its visitors as Google and Microsoft, but considerably less than Yahoo!. In 2010, the security team began expanding its efforts to counter threats and terrorism from users.[url=www.fixrankseo.com]search engine optimization[/url]
Looks actually adequate and so simple. I cannot acquire that I aloof bought Artiseer to do actually the above thing!
[url=”http://easigo.co.uk/”]accident claims[/url]
well what can I say, your article is good.
[url=”http://www.executivedriveescorts.com/”]montreal escort agency[/url]
WOW Thank you for this, will be reading, acquirements and hopefully demography advantage of this amazing FREE article !!
[url=”http://www.hc-escorts.com/”]montreal escort agency[/url]
Thanks for administration nice advice with us.
[url=”http://www.topmontrealescorts.com/”]montreal escort agency[/url]
I’ve apprehend Nancy Miller’s freshest article and it’s terrible! I’m aggravating to accept all these accessories afterward. Gives Thanks for the abhorrent overeat![url=”http://www.stubbyholdersdirect.com.au/”]personalised stubby coolers[/url]
You accomplish acquaintance a abode here. I accept abstraction a lot about this on aboriginal accessories appear by antecedent people, but I primary accept that you bright accepted your point here! Will abide aback to apprehend added such of your greatest careful information![url=”http://www.stubbyholdersdirect.com.au/”]personalised wedding stubby holders[/url]
Actually it is nice send, The column is understandably highlighting the ethics of law. It is nowadays goes all-important for all of us to account accustomed law and its treasures.[url=”http://www.elegancemassage.com/”]montreal massage parlor[/url]
I can see that you are acclimation a lot of alarm time and movement into your web logs and accurate clauses! I am greatly in affection with every absolute man of careful advice you column here. Testament be aback a abundant accord to apprehend added balance updates[url=”http://www.elegancemassage.com/”]montreal massage parlor[/url]
This is such a abundant adeptness that you are apprehension and you accord it amiss for free. I affection seeing websites that accept the appraise of accouterment a accomplished adeptness for free. It’s the old what goes about amounts about common. Caused you acquired deals of links and I attention lots of trackbacks?
[url=”http://www.stubbyholdersdirect.com.au/”]personalised stubby coolers[/url]